Family Pizzera in Marysville

Awesome food and service!

This place was amazing when ran by Benny. I took my mom tonite to celebrate her birthday and it was AWFUL! THE ONE OWNERS MOTHER AND DAUGHTER WERE TERRIBLE! They have evidently never heard of customer service. Sometimes family working for you works out( like Kellie, Mike, Sean, and Timmy O'conners) unfortunately this family does not respect their parents like the O'conners kids do. With these new owners I expect to see more bad reviews. TAKE THIS PLACE BACK BENNY AND PEGGY AND MAKE IT GREAT AGAIN!

Pizza was really good. Italian sub, salad, and wings were great. The BBQ sauce on wings was awesome and the wings were big. The pretzel appetizer was okay. Service was great. They serve free popcorn! I would recommend to anyone looking for a good pizzeria.

Drove from Westerville and it's well worth the drive best pizza we have had in a long time and well worth the money thank you so much we will definitely be back

Gluten free crust is thin and crispy. A rare and wonderful find.

Great pizza. A little pricier than I expected. And also an extremely long wait(1 hour and 12 min) for pizza on a Friday night.

Been here a couple of times and I think they have the best pizza in Marysville, along with Benny's, not sure if it's the same owners or anything but to me they taste exactly the same-Very Good! And the service was great as well! Definitely recommend and will be back!

Good pizza

Tonight was our first time eating here and we will be back for sure. The chicken fingers were maybe the best I’ve ever had, very authentic quality flavor and the perfect amount of breading. It was our daughter’s 1st time eating pizza and that girl devoured it! Nice job guys.

Great pizza with great service. Will definitely come back.

Good pizza. Good value. Good beer.

Pizza was great, you must have the cinnamon sticks! Cute and cozy little place

Very good mom and pop pizza place. Excellent food.

We love this place. Great pizza, fresh ingredients, great subs, wings are normal size (not GMO size) and the sauces are full of flavor. Hands down favorite pizza in marysville. Yes, better than Benny’s. Beer is cold. Free popcorn while you wait. I have also ordered 12, extra large pizzas for a party at 10:30am. I called the day before to order and they opened their doors and had all the pizzas done and fresh that early on a Saturday!! Amazing service. We will continue to frequent this place.

Good food, great prices!!

Great staff, clean restrooms, great take out pizza.

Love this little neighborhood pizza place! Great food, friends and service!

Friendly staff! Pizza was ok. Not really my style, yet good. Boys loved it!

We’re not from around here but work not far from the pizza restaurant occasionally. We bought the Friday family deal an it was as awesome. Marysville you guys are lucky to have a gem like this here.

Excellent pizza! Everything we've gotten here has been really good.

I love family pizza, I always come here when I'm in town. It's hot and there's no better place to get a pizza thank you Kelly

Comfy little pizzaria with beer and great food. The pizza ranks right up there with Bakers or Bennys. Highly recommend this place.

My go to pizza joint. Also they're adding a patio

I find the people who answer the phones to be kind of neutral, not necessarily friendly and not really rude. But dog on their food is delicious. I would personally allow them to slap me in the face for their Cinnamon pretzel bites. Their subs are excellent! And I didn't even mention the pizza, also heaven in your mouth.

Excellent food reasonably priced

Great food pleasant atmosphere great service very clean. Decent price

Pizza was hot and very fresh! Buckeye Pizza was HOPPING!

I hate to admit it growing up on Benny's from the late 80's till present but we tried Buckeye Family Pizzeria a week ago and it's our go to pizza place for pizza and subs from now on. Absolutely fantastic food!!! Thanks for great food guys and great prices!!!

Pizza excellent as always! Love the freshly popped popcorn they give you as you sit down at the table. Look forward to that! 👍 I had their pretzel bites for the first time and they were warm and yummy. They serve with cheese sauce or honey mustard... both were very good. Highly recommend Buckeye Family Pizzeria! Give it a try!

The food and service was excellent! The bacon and pepperoni pizza was sub par with the grease it burnt the top. Everything else was super

Great food and amazing service!

Only had the pizza, but it was delicious. Had a class reunion there & they were very accommodating.

Nice little place in Marysville. We stopped in after a basketball tournament and was not disappointed! If you are in the area you have to check them out! Crispy thin crust, cheesy, and loaded! Cinnamon sticks were a got with the wife and kids too.

Amazing. Griffin was cool!! Awesome pizza!!

It is a very good pizza 😎🤙

Tasty pizza- We had a beer and some pretzel bites while we waited for our order. The wait staff was friendly and attentive. A nice family establishment. I would recommend giving it a try!

Second day after they reopened and it's amazing what they have done with the place!! The remodel is amazing!! The food was great (as always!) But it was so nice to sit down and enjoy the new layout!!

Couple weeks ago we had it for the first time, was outstanding!

Great place good people good food breadsticks are delicious

Family friendly! Server and cook went out of their way to make our 39th anniversary memorable!!!

This could be the best pizza in town great people also

Reaaly good pizza and staff went the extra mile to serve us. Thank you!

Best pizza place in Marysville. I’ve been going here since I was a little kid and it’s hands down the best.

Best Pizza and coldest beer. Would highly recommend. Yes it is a little more expensive than chain pizza stores but the dough is made fresh daily which gives it that fresh taste. Well worth it

Food was really good. Staff friendly and helpful.

It has a very relaxed atmosphere, friendly staff and awesome pizza and wings. The front patio is definitely a great improvement to the establishment.

Great Pizza and service!

Very good pizza. Newly remodeled with cool interior and patio.

Best Pizza, Subs and Garlic Parmesan wings around

This Place has changed ownership about 1 year ago and what a big difference. The pizza is thin crust and they use old world pepperoni. The toppings are generous and other items on the menu are good. Dinning in is small for larger groups so plan ahead for parties larger than 8.